Note: The Boulders and Rockets traded draft positions except for round three.
Trivia fact for 2005: Perennial fantasy disappointment wide receiver Derrick Mason was selected no fewer than three times.
| Round | WelshVillage Weasels | Stoney Point Boulders | Dodos | Thermopolis Thermos | Ranier Rockets | Orange and Brew | Maltodextrin | IA Skins | Robins Hoods | CR Witz | Insert Name Here | Marion Muddogs |
| 1 | Ladainian Tomlinson | Shaun Alexander | Priest Holmes | Clinton Portis | Edgerrin James | Peyton Manning | Daunte Culpepper | Willis McGahee | Deuce McAllister | Domanick Davis | Jamal Lewis | Curtis Martin |
| RB | RB | RB | RB | RB | QB | QB | RB | RB | RB | RB | RB | |
| SD | SEA | KC | WAS | IND | IND | MIN | BUF | NO | HOU | BAL | NYJ | |
| 2 | Brian Westbrook | Steven Jackson | Torry Holt | Mike Anderson | Rudi Johnson | Tiki Barber | Kevin Jones | Chad Johnson | Corey Dillon | Julius Jones | Randy Moss | Tom Brady |
| RB | RB | WR | RB | RB | RB | RB | WR | RB | RB | WR | QB | |
| PHI | STL | STL | DEN | CIN | NYG | DET | CIN | NE | DAL | OAK | NE | |
| 3 | Marvin Harrison | Terrell Owens | Ahman Green | Javon Walker | Lamont Jordan | Warrick Dunn | Reggie Wayne | Donovan McNabb | Tony Gonzalez | Antonio Gates | Andre Johnson | Joe Horn |
| WR | WR | RB | WR | RB | RB | WR | QB | TE | TE | WR | WR | |
| IND | PHI | GB | GB | OAK | ATL | IND | PHI | KC | SD | HOU | NO | |
| 4 | Jerome Bettis | Marc Bulger | BAL Defense | Anquan Boldin | Jason Witten | Nate Burleson | Darrell Jackson | JJ Arrington | Trent Green | Ronnie Brown | Tatum Bell | Dallas Clark |
| RB | QB | WR | TE | WR | WR | RB | QB | RB | RB | TE | ||
| PIT | STL | ARI | DAL | MIN | SEA | ARI | KC | MIA | DEN | IND | ||
| 5 | Hines Ward | Chris Brown | Michael Vick | Ashley Lelie | Steve Smith | Roy Williams | Cedric Benson | Todd Heap | Carnell Williams | Brett Favre | Aaron Brooks | Mike Vanderjagt |
| WR | RB | QB | WR | WR | WR | RB | TE | RB | QB | QB | K | |
| PIT | TEN | ATL | DEN | CAR | DET | CHI | BAL | TB | GB | NO | IND | |
| 6 | Carson Palmer | De'shaun Foster | Alge Crumpler | Byron Leftwich | Fred Taylor | Jeremy Shockey | Michael Bennett | Donald Driver | PIT Defense | BUF Defense | Michael Clayton | NE Defense |
| QB | RB | TE | QB | RB | TE | RB | WR | WR | ||||
| CIN | CAR | ATL | JAC | JAC | NYG | MIN | GB | TB | ||||
| 7 | Drew Bennett | Larry Johnson | Kevan Barlow | PHI Defense | Laveranues Coles | Travis Henry | David Akers | Mewelde Moore | Mushin Muhammad | Isaac Bruce | Adam Vinatieri | Deion Branch |
| WR | RB | RB | WR | RB | K | RB | WR | WR | K | WR | ||
| TEN | KC | SF | NYJ | TEN | PHI | MIN | CHI | STL | NE | NE | ||
| 8 | Jeff Wilkins | Jason Elam | Jimmy Smith | Willie Parker | Jake Plummer | CAR Defense | Lee Evans | Santana Moss | Jerry Porter | Ricky Williams | Larry Fitzgerald | Matt Hasselbeck |
| K | K | WR | RB | QB | WR | WR | WR | RB | WR | QB | ||
| STL | DEN | JAC | PIT | DEN | BUF | WAS | OAK | MIA | ARI | SEA | ||
| 9 | Eddie Kennison | ATL Defense | Lee Suggs | Ryan Longwell | Sebastian Janikowski | Rod Smith | Chris Chambers | Thomas Jones | Kerry Collins | Matt Stover | Duce Staley | TJ Duckett |
| WR | RB | K | K | WR | WR | RB | QB | K | RB | RB | ||
| KC | CLE | GB | OAK | DEN | MIA | CHI | OAK | BAL | PIT | ATL | ||
| 10 | TB Defense | Michael Jenkins | Kurt Warner | Chad Pennington | Plaxico Burress | Jeff Reed | Marshall Faulk | Shayne Graham | Eric Moulds | Brandon Jacobs | Drew Brees | Brandon Stokely |
| WR | QB | QB | WR | K | RB | K | WR | RB | QB | WR | ||
| ATL | ARI | NYJ | NYG | PIT | STL | CIN | BUF | NYG | SD | IND | ||
| 11 | Braylon Edwards | Michael Pittman | Randy McMichael | Jermaine Wiggins | Keyshawn Johnson | David Carr | TJ Houshmandzadeh | Eric Johnson | Reuben Droughns | Eric Shelton | Bubba Franks | Reche Caldwell |
| WR | RB | TE | TE | WR | QB | WR | TE | RB | RB | TE | WR | |
| CLE | TB | MIA | MIN | DAL | HOU | CIN | SF | CLE | CAR | GB | SD | |
| 12 | Dominic Rhodes | Marcel Shipp | Donte' Stallworth | Najeh Davenport | Jake Delhomme | Labrandon Toefield | Chris Cooley | MIN Defense | Anthony Thomas | Derrick Mason | Chester Taylor | LJ Smith |
| RB | RB | WR | RB | QB | RB | TE | RB | WR | RB | TE | ||
| IND | ARI | NO | GB | CAR | JAC | WAS | DAL | TEN | BAL | PHI | ||
| 13 | Heath Miller | Ladell Betts | Josh Brown | NYJ Defense | WAS Defense | Daniel Graham | Ciatrick Fason | Ben Roethlisberger | Kyle Orton | Steve McNair | CIN Defense | Justin Fargas |
| TE | RB | K | TE | RB | QB | QB | QB | RB | ||||
| PIT | WAS | SEA | NE | MIN | PIT | CHI | TEN | OAK | ||||
| 14 | Brian Griese | Derrick Blaylock | Amani Toomer | Lamar Gordon | Greg Lewis | Antwaan Randle El | IND Defense | Moe Williams | Neil Rackers | Kevin Curtis | Charles Rogers | DAL Defense |
| QB | RB | WR | RB | WR | WR | RB | K | WR | WR | |||
| TB | NYJ | NYG | MIA | PHI | PIT | MIN | ARI | STL | DET | |||
| 15 | JAC Defense | Marcus Pollard | Tim Dwight | Tyrone Calico | Jeb Putzier | SD Defense | Keary Colbert | Ben Watson | Mike Alstott | Frank Gore | Chris Perry | Nate Kaeding |
| TE | WR | WR | TE | WR | TE | RB | RB | RB | K | |||
| DET | NE | TEN | DEN | CAR | NE | TB | SF | CIN | SD |